78.2 F
Cypress
Sunday, May 31, 2020

Human Rights-Humanitarian Divide

Must read

100 Years From Now…

"A 100 years from now, it will not matter what kind of car I drove, what kind of house I lived in,...

COVID-19 Evictions Relief

Shortly after announcing the mortgage relief order, the California Governor Gavin Newsom issued an order for eviction relief for residential tenants.

COVID-19 Mortgage Relief

What is it? Governor Gavin Newsom announced a deal (Business Insider, 3/25/2020) with the major banks on a 90-day...

Moon should offer the U.S. $2.5 Trillion

President Moon should take the initiative and make an offer President Trump can’t refuse. He should offer not $5 billion but $2.5 trillion. In exchange, President Moon would ask the U.S. to agree to a New Comprehensive Peace Regime.
SPEDDI
SPEDDI = Sustainable Peace, Economic Development, Democracy, and Innovation. Charles Park has a BA in Political Economy of Industrial Societies (PEIS) from UC Berkeley (1991) and an MA in Pacific and International Affairs from the School of Global Policy, UC San Diego (1995).

Excellent piece by Eric Weingartner published by 38 North (“Reconciling the Human Factor: Understanding the North Korean Human Rights/Humanitarian Divide”, 5/2013) on the divide between Humanitarian Activism and Human Rights Activism.

Not only do their goals and methods often contradict each other, their practitioners sometimes engage in verbal battles and mutual recrimination….

Humanitarian agencies aim to ease human suffering. Human rights organizations aim to outlawhuman suffering.
Humanitarians work within whatever is the prevailing system, in order to deliver commodities, tools and skills to those in need. Human rights activists work to changesystems that they believe are the cause of assaults on human dignity.
Humanitarians aim to raise the living standards of those without power. Human rights aim to enforce standards of behavior on those in power.


The most widely used tactic in the toolkit of human rights activists is exposing the misdeeds of violators and putting international pressure on them to alter their behavior. In other words, “blame and shame.” Naturally, the most eager allies in such campaigns are countries that are enemies of the country whose behavior you want to change. And this leaves a fertile soil for political manipulation.

The human rights deficit is considered to be so extreme in North Korea that the only solution is regime change. This is unlikely to evolve through internal reform. Therefore every conceivable pressure should be put on the DPRK, including—if necessary—military means. North Korean human rights conditions should be condemned at all levels in all countries, in the media, and of course at the United Nations. Human rights concerns should be part of every negotiation involving North Korea, including the stalled Six Party Talks that deal with the nuclear issue.

Although humanitarian agencies shy away from voicing political opinions in public, my private conversations with relief workers in the DPRK reveal that many consider the actions taken by the powers surrounding North Korea singularly ill-advised. Threatening violence against North Korea by military means merely intensifies the atmosphere of crisis and fear that is already experienced by its population, and thereby provides the rationale that feeds the regime’s repressive apparatus. Humanitarians generally agree that neither war nor the threat of war advance the cause of human rights.

Source: Eric Weingartner, 38 North

Photo Credit: UN

The photo was taken during Under-Secretary-General for Humanitarian Affairs Valerie Amos’ five-day mission in the country to assess food aid needs.

Photo ID 492097. 20/10/2011. Wonsan City, DPRK. UN Photo/David Ohana.

- Advertisement -

More articles

- Advertisement -

Latest article

100 Years From Now…

"A 100 years from now, it will not matter what kind of car I drove, what kind of house I lived in,...

COVID-19 Evictions Relief

Shortly after announcing the mortgage relief order, the California Governor Gavin Newsom issued an order for eviction relief for residential tenants.

COVID-19 Mortgage Relief

What is it? Governor Gavin Newsom announced a deal (Business Insider, 3/25/2020) with the major banks on a 90-day...

Moon should offer the U.S. $2.5 Trillion

President Moon should take the initiative and make an offer President Trump can’t refuse. He should offer not $5 billion but $2.5 trillion. In exchange, President Moon would ask the U.S. to agree to a New Comprehensive Peace Regime.

Compost me on the trails

Washington became the first state to legalize the composting of human remains (May 22, 2019, CNN). In "human composting," the body remains are...
%d bloggers like this: