74 F
Cypress
Sunday, July 12, 2020

Mexico tried giving poor people cash instead of food. It worked.

Must read

100 Years From Now…

"A 100 years from now, it will not matter what kind of car I drove, what kind of house I lived in,...

COVID-19 Evictions Relief

Shortly after announcing the mortgage relief order, the California Governor Gavin Newsom issued an order for eviction relief for residential tenants.

COVID-19 Mortgage Relief

What is it? Governor Gavin Newsom announced a deal (Business Insider, 3/25/2020) with the major banks on a 90-day...

Moon should offer the U.S. $2.5 Trillion

President Moon should take the initiative and make an offer President Trump can’t refuse. He should offer not $5 billion but $2.5 trillion. In exchange, President Moon would ask the U.S. to agree to a New Comprehensive Peace Regime.
SPEDDI
SPEDDI = Sustainable Peace, Economic Development, Democracy, and Innovation. Charles Park has a BA in Political Economy of Industrial Societies (PEIS) from UC Berkeley (1991) and an MA in Pacific and International Affairs from the School of Global Policy, UC San Diego (1995).

In the United States, most government aid takes the form of in-kind transfers: that is, the government gives you stuff, or a voucher to buy specific stuff, rather than just cash to buy whatever you like. That has led to a panoply of programs.

..

In the study, Naval Postgraduate School’s Jesse Cunha looks at the Mexican government’s food assistance program, known as Programa de Apoyo Alimentario (loosely translated to Food Aid Program, or PAL).

Evaluating the experimental data, Cunha finds that “both cash and in-kind transfers increased total consumption relative to no transfer, and that effect sizes are indistinguishable from one another.”

Cunha does find evidence that consumption of micro-nutrients like vitamin C and zinc is higher for mothers and children getting the food than those getting the cash, but no evidence of differences in actual health.

And there’s another big drawback to giving food rather than cash: it costs more to administer. Cunha notes that distributing PAL’s in-kind transfers costs about 20 percent of the cost of the food, but that the distribution costs of Mexico’s main cash transfer program, Progresa-Oportunidades, amount to 2.4 percent of the cash distributed.

Read more here: Mexico tried giving poor people cash instead of food. It worked.

Photo Credit: Miguel Discart

Footnotes: See also the case of Bolsa Familia and Uganda

- Advertisement -

More articles

- Advertisement -

Latest article

100 Years From Now…

"A 100 years from now, it will not matter what kind of car I drove, what kind of house I lived in,...

COVID-19 Evictions Relief

Shortly after announcing the mortgage relief order, the California Governor Gavin Newsom issued an order for eviction relief for residential tenants.

COVID-19 Mortgage Relief

What is it? Governor Gavin Newsom announced a deal (Business Insider, 3/25/2020) with the major banks on a 90-day...

Moon should offer the U.S. $2.5 Trillion

President Moon should take the initiative and make an offer President Trump can’t refuse. He should offer not $5 billion but $2.5 trillion. In exchange, President Moon would ask the U.S. to agree to a New Comprehensive Peace Regime.

Compost me on the trails

Washington became the first state to legalize the composting of human remains (May 22, 2019, CNN). In "human composting," the body remains are...
%d bloggers like this: